Transforming Differentiation: How AI Can Help Teachers Meet Every Student's Needs

Transforming Differentiation: How AI Can Help Teachers Meet Every Student's Needs

Explore practical, AI-powered strategies to personalize learning, streamline planning, and meet diverse student needs in today’s classrooms.

By Joshua Kaufmann & AI

•
education AI teaching differentiation

Today’s classrooms are vibrant mosaics of learning needs, styles, and backgrounds. As teachers, we strive to reach every student where they are—a mission often challenged by tight schedules and mounting responsibilities. Enter artificial intelligence (AI): a tool that’s reshaping how we approach differentiation, offering ways to tailor instruction without overwhelming our already full plates.

Drawing from my own classroom experiments and the latest trends as of February 26, 2025, I’ve found AI can amplify our efforts to create responsive learning environments. This post dives into actionable strategies that harness AI to enhance differentiation—not to replace your teaching expertise, but to make your best work more achievable.

Why AI and Differentiation Go Hand in Hand

Differentiation adapts teaching to suit students’ varied readiness levels, learning styles, and interests. As Anam Javed from the Victorian Academy of Teaching and Leadership points out, “Differentiated learning aligns perfectly with the capabilities of AI” because it can produce tailored resources quickly—tasks that once took hours ([Victorian Academy, 2024]). With 58% of university instructors now using generative AI daily, its potential in education is clear ([Springs Apps, 2025]).

AI doesn’t aim to automate teaching; it clears the deck of repetitive tasks, freeing us to focus on relationships and targeted support. Let’s explore how to put it to work practically.

Strategic Approaches for AI-Enhanced Differentiation

Enhancing Content Accessibility

AI excels at adapting materials to suit all learners. Here’s how it can help:

  • Multi-level reading passages: Turn one text into versions at different reading levels, keeping core concepts intact. Tools like Diffit already do this, and AI can replicate it with the right prompts ([Student-Centered World, 2025]).
  • Vocabulary scaffolds: Build tiered word lists—from simple definitions with visuals to advanced scientific breakdowns.
  • Comprehension supports: Craft pre-, during-, and post-reading aids at varying complexity levels.

Specific prompts get the best results. Here are some to try:

Example Prompt for Reading Passages:
Create three versions of this passage about the water cycle for 6th graders:

  1. Below-grade level (4th grade reading)
  2. On-grade level (6th grade reading)
  3. Above-grade level (8th grade reading)
    Keep key terms (evaporation, condensation, precipitation) consistent across all.

Sample Passage:
“The water cycle is how water moves around Earth. It starts with evaporation, when water from oceans and lakes turns into vapor and rises into the air. Then, condensation happens as the vapor cools and forms clouds. Finally, precipitation falls as rain or snow, putting water back on the ground to start again.”

Output Sample:

  • Below-grade (4th grade): “The water cycle is how water travels. Evaporation is when water from lakes goes up into the air as vapor. Condensation makes clouds when the vapor gets cold. Precipitation is rain or snow that falls back down.”
  • On-grade (6th grade): “The water cycle moves water around Earth. Evaporation lifts water from oceans and lakes into the air as vapor. Condensation turns that vapor into clouds as it cools. Precipitation, like rain or snow, brings water back to the ground.”
  • Above-grade (8th grade): “The water cycle circulates Earth’s water continuously. Evaporation transforms liquid water from bodies like oceans into gaseous vapor that ascends. Condensation occurs as this vapor cools, forming clouds. Precipitation then returns water to the surface as rain, snow, or other forms.”

Example Prompt for Vocabulary Application:
Create a set of differentiated sentences using these 8 climate change terms for 6th graders:

  • Greenhouse effect
  • Carbon footprint
  • Fossil fuels
  • Renewable energy
  • Deforestation
  • Global warming
  • Emissions
  • Sustainability
    For each term, provide:
  1. A simple sentence (3rd grade level)
  2. A visual cue or metaphor to pair with it
  3. An advanced sentence with technical detail (8th grade level)
  4. A 2025 real-world context sentence

Output Sample:

  • Greenhouse Effect

    1. Simple: “The greenhouse effect keeps Earth warm with gases.”
    2. Visual: “Like a cozy blanket over the planet.”
    3. Advanced: “The greenhouse effect traps infrared radiation, raising Earth’s temperature due to increased carbon dioxide.”
    4. Context: “In 2025, the greenhouse effect made summers in Europe hotter than ever.”

  • Carbon Footprint

    1. Simple: “Your carbon footprint grows when you drive a lot.”
    2. Visual: “Like leaving smoky footprints behind you.”
    3. Advanced: “A carbon footprint measures the greenhouse gases released by daily activities like transportation and energy use.”
    4. Context: “In 2025, kids in New York used an app to shrink their carbon footprint.”

  • Fossil Fuels

    1. Simple: “Fossil fuels like coal give us power but make smoke.”
    2. Visual: “Like burning old rocks from the ground.”
    3. Advanced: “Fossil fuels, such as oil and gas, release stored carbon into the atmosphere when burned for energy.”
    4. Context: “In 2025, California used less fossil fuels as solar power grew.”

  • Renewable Energy

    1. Simple: “Renewable energy comes from wind and sun.”
    2. Visual: “Like a windmill spinning all day.”
    3. Advanced: “Renewable energy harnesses natural resources like solar radiation and wind to generate electricity sustainably.”
    4. Context: “In 2025, renewable energy from turbines lit up homes in Denmark.”

  • Deforestation

    1. Simple: “Deforestation happens when we cut down trees.”
    2. Visual: “Like erasing a big green forest.”
    3. Advanced: “Deforestation disrupts ecosystems by removing trees that absorb carbon dioxide, worsening climate change.”
    4. Context: “In 2025, deforestation slowed in Brazil thanks to new rules.”

  • Global Warming

    1. Simple: “Global warming makes Earth hotter.”
    2. Visual: “Like turning up the planet’s heat dial.”
    3. Advanced: “Global warming results from greenhouse gas buildup, elevating Earth’s average temperature over time.”
    4. Context: “In 2025, global warming melted ice, flooding streets in Miami.”

  • Emissions

    1. Simple: “Emissions come from cars and make the air dirty.”
    2. Visual: “Like smoke puffing from a tailpipe.”
    3. Advanced: “Emissions, including carbon dioxide and methane, are pollutants released by burning fuels, impacting air quality.”
    4. Context: “In 2025, emissions dropped as electric ships sailed in Asia.”

  • Sustainability

    1. Simple: “Sustainability means saving resources for later.”
    2. Visual: “Like planting seeds for future trees.”
    3. Advanced: “Sustainability balances resource use to preserve ecosystems and support long-term environmental health.”
    4. Context: “In 2025, sustainability efforts in Tokyo recycled most of the city’s trash.”

Differentiating Process and Activities

AI can diversify how students engage with content, offering multiple pathways:

  • Tiered question sets: Produce questions ranging from recall to analysis, matching student ability levels. The Animated Teacher blog champions this for quick differentiation ([The Animated Teacher, 2024]).
  • Scaffolded activities: Design tasks with adjustable support—guided for some, open-ended for others.
  • Interest-based connections: Link lessons to students’ passions, boosting engagement.

Try these prompts:

Example Prompt for Tiered Questions: Create 3 question sets about World War II for 9th graders:

  • Set 1 (Basic): 5 recall questions on dates and events
  • Set 2 (Intermediate): 5 questions on causes and effects
  • Set 3 (Advanced): 5 questions analyzing perspectives or modern parallels Include answer keys.

Output Sample:

  • Set 1 (Basic):
    1. When did World War II start? (1939)
    2. Who was Germany’s leader? (Adolf Hitler)
    3. What year did the U.S. join? (1941)
    4. Name one Allied country. (e.g., United States)
    5. When did the war end? (1945)
  • Set 2 (Intermediate):
    1. What caused Germany to invade Poland? (Expansion goals)
    2. How did Pearl Harbor affect the war? (U.S. entry)
    3. Why did the Allies win D-Day? (Planning, numbers)
    4. What was the effect of rationing? (Resource support)
    5. How did the war change Europe? (Borders redrawn)
  • Set 3 (Advanced):
    1. How did propaganda shape public views? (Varied by country)
    2. Compare Allied and Axis strategies. (e.g., Blitzkrieg vs. island-hopping)
    3. Analyze a leader’s decision—good or bad? (e.g., Hitler’s Russia invasion)
    4. How does WWII connect to 2025 conflicts? (e.g., alliance patterns)
    5. Evaluate a primary source’s reliability. (e.g., speech bias)

Example Prompt for Scaffolded Activities: Design a three-tiered activity on Newton’s Laws for 7th-grade science:

  • Tier 1: Step-by-step experiment with prompts
  • Tier 2: Guided inquiry with some choice
  • Tier 3: Student-designed investigation Include objectives, materials, instructions, and assessment criteria.

Output Sample:

  • Tier 1:
    • Objective: Understand Newton’s First Law (inertia).
    • Materials: Ball, flat surface, ruler.
    • Instructions: Roll the ball. Stop it with the ruler. Answer: Why did it stop? (Force applied.)
    • Criteria: Completes steps, answers correctly (3 points).
  • Tier 2:
    • Objective: Apply Newton’s Second Law (force = mass × acceleration).
    • Materials: Ball, ramp, weights.
    • Instructions: Test how weights affect ball speed down the ramp. Choose two weights. Record results.
    • Criteria: Accurate data, basic conclusion (5 points).
  • Tier 3:
    • Objective: Explore Newton’s Third Law (action-reaction).
    • Materials: Student choice (e.g., balloon, string).
    • Instructions: Design an experiment to show equal/opposite reactions. Test and explain.
    • Criteria: Clear design, data, and analysis (7 points).

Example Prompt for Interest-Based Connections: For my 5th graders learning fractions, create practice problems tied to:

  1. Sports
  2. Gaming
  3. Cooking
  4. Music
  5. Art Provide 3 problems per interest, using real-world contexts.

Output Sample:

  • Sports:
    1. A team played 3/4 of a game before rain. How much is left? (1/4)
    2. A player scored 2/5 of the points. What’s 3/5 more? (5/5 or 1)
    3. Practice is 1/2 hour. How long is 2 sessions? (1 hour)
  • Gaming:
    1. You finish 1/3 of a level. How much is left? (2/3)
    2. A boss takes 3/4 health to beat. What’s 1/4 more? (1)
    3. A game is 2/5 done after 10 minutes. How long total? (25 minutes)

Transforming Assessment Approaches

AI can refresh how we gauge understanding, making assessments more inclusive:

  • Alternative assessments: Suggest creative ways for students to show mastery beyond tests.
  • Formative check-ins: Generate quick, varied checks to track progress.
  • Reflection prompts: Craft questions to foster self-awareness at different stages.

Be precise with assessment prompts:

Example Prompt for Alternative Assessments: Suggest 5 ways 8th graders can show understanding of photosynthesis beyond a quiz:

  1. Format (e.g., poster, video)
  2. Key concepts to cover
  3. 3-4 rubric criteria
  4. Modifications for diverse learners

Output Sample:

  1. Format: Poster
    • Concepts: Light, water, CO2 → glucose, oxygen.
    • Criteria: Clarity, accuracy, visuals (10 points).
    • Modification: Provide a template for visual learners.
  2. Format: Video skit
    • Concepts: Plant process, energy transfer.
    • Criteria: Content, creativity, delivery (12 points).
    • Modification: Script prompts for language support.

Example Prompt for Formative Assessments: Create three exit tickets for a 4th-grade decimals lesson:

  • Version 1: Basic (simple calculations)
  • Version 2: Intermediate (word problems)
  • Version 3: Advanced (reasoning tasks) Each takes 5 minutes and checks place value understanding.

Output Sample:

  • Version 1: Circle 0.5, 0.05, 0.005. Which is biggest? (0.5)
  • Version 2: A candy costs $0.75. You pay $1.00. What’s your change? ($0.25)
  • Version 3: Why is 0.40 > 0.4? Explain. (Same value, precision matters)

Example Prompt for Reflection Questions: Generate reflection prompts for 6th graders after a narrative writing unit:

  • Emerging writers: 3 process-focused questions
  • Developing writers: 3 growth-comparison questions
  • Advanced writers: 3 style-deepening questions

Output Sample:

  • Emerging:
    1. What was easiest about writing your story?
    2. What step was hard?
    3. What will you try next time?
  • Developing:
    1. How is this story better than your last?
    2. What improved most?
    3. What’s one goal for next time?
  • Advanced:
    1. How did you make your voice unique?
    2. What author inspired you?
    3. How will you push your style further?

Practical Implementation Tips

Master Prompt Engineering

Great AI outputs start with great prompts. “Rich prompts create customized, engaging learning experiences,” says Javed ([Victorian Academy, 2024]). Be specific about:

  • Grade and subject
  • Learning goals
  • Differentiation levels
  • Examples if needed

Prioritize High-Impact Areas

Start where AI saves the most time—like multi-level texts or tiered questions—addressing your students’ biggest needs with reusable outputs.

Build a System

  • Prompt library: Save effective prompts in a spreadsheet (e.g., Title: “Tiered Question Generator,” Subject: “History,” Prompt: [text]).
  • Student profiles: Use this prompt to create templates: Help me craft description templates for common learning needs in my classroom. For each area (reading, writing, processing, engagement, background, language), suggest 4-5 phrases for differentiation planning.
  • Collaborate: Share successes with colleagues.

Beyond Individual Resources

AI’s power extends to broader differentiation:

Analyzing Student Data

Spot trends in student work to refine your approach: I’ve assessed my 5th graders on multiplication. Common issues:

  • Group 1: Skip-counting errors
  • Group 2: Misapplying the standard algorithm
  • Group 3: Slow fact recall For each, suggest:
  1. The skill gap
  2. A mini-lesson
  3. A practice activity

Output Sample:

  • Group 1:
    1. Gap: Misunderstanding counting patterns.
    2. Mini-lesson: Use a number line to count by 3s.
    3. Activity: Flashcards with skip-count sequences.

Brainstorming Strategies

Get fresh ideas for lessons: Suggest 5 ways to teach ratios to 7th graders using different modalities (visual, kinesthetic, musical, logical, verbal). Include descriptions, materials, and differentiation tips.

Output Sample:

  1. Visual: Draw ratio bars; paper, markers; simplify for struggling learners.

Generating Feedback Templates

Streamline feedback: Create 3 feedback templates for student essays:

  • Emerging: Encouragement-focused
  • Developing: Structure-focused
  • Advanced: Depth-focused Include openings, 3 feedback areas, 2-3 reflection questions, and closings.

Output Sample:

  • Emerging:
    • Opening: “Great start on your essay!”
    • Feedback: Effort, 1 strength, 1 tip.
    • Questions: What was fun? What’s next?
    • Closing: “Keep it up!”

Keeping the Human Touch

AI supports, but doesn’t replace, your judgment. UNESCO’s 2025 focus on AI in education stresses ethical use—tools like Google’s Gemini enhance efficiency, but you bring the context and connection ([UNESCO, 2025]; [Google, 2025]). Balance AI with your:

  • Student knowledge
  • Content mastery
  • Ongoing adjustments
  • Encouragement

Moving Forward: Start Small, Scale Up

“The potential of AI-driven platforms is undeniable,” notes Edcafe AI, “but consider their real classroom impact” ([Edcafe AI, 2025]). Begin with one strategy: I’m new to AI differentiation for my 5th-grade math class on fractions. Students struggle with equivalence. Suggest:

  1. An easy strategy
  2. A prompt for materials
  3. How to assess its success

Output Sample:

  1. Strategy: Use visuals like fraction bars.
  2. Prompt: Create 3 fraction bar worksheets (1/2, 1/4, 1/8) with examples.
  3. Assessment: Check if students match equivalents correctly.

AI makes differentiation doable, not daunting. Let’s use it to meet every student’s needs without burning out.

Sources:

Have a Question About These Solutions?

Whether you're curious about implementation details or want to know how these approaches might work in your context, I'm happy to help.

Ask a Question Read Success Stories
← Back to Blog